dingle, there are a couple differences in Lawrence /HH comparison. For one thing, Clemson was coming off the DeShaun Watson years and Dabo loved the results. Then the next year, he had that Bryant kid, who was a pretty good QB, but was not going to be the difference maker that Dabo wanted. Even with Watson and a loaded squad, they barely got past Bama. So if there's one thing Dabo knows is how good a team has to be to win it all.
So, early on Lawrence got in, later Bryant transferred, I think to Missouri and as it turns out, Dabo was right since Trevor was a great college QB and Bryant was a good QB.
Dabo also had an over abundance of 1st round draft picks on the DL, and that combo led Dabo to the national title. Had Dabo stayed with Bryant, there's no avenue for that same level of success.
It doesn't make any difference if its Saban, Meyer, Swinney, Osborne or whomever, those top, top coaches recognize great talent when they see it.
Saban pulls Hurts at halftime and inserts Tua who helps win the title.
Meyer wins the national title with the 3rd string QB.
Swinney wins the title with Watson and 2 years later is back with Trevor.
Tom made no bones about Tommie being the most valuable player for the team he ever had.
You suppose that's what separates the good coaches from the great ones?
Moral of the story? HH in practice likely hasn't shown that he is gonna be that type of difference maker, so Rhule chooses to go with the experience, and to hell with the turnover issue.
To me, the prevailing point is: Does Sims have what it takes to lead this team to victories? Forget West Division title or Big Ten title. Thus far the answer is no.
The question is, is this the best decision for the other 100 kids on the team?
**Edit** Last year Whipple (for whatever reason) wanted no part of HH. No doubt, CT was a superior QB. If, HH had "it" then maybe the narrative changes and he's not bypassed by a less than productive Purdy.
We DON'T know what the actual reason is this excellent physical specimen can not get on the field. Do we even know if this kids has the smarts or savvy to lead a 10-12 play drive and make the calls and check calls that it takes against good teams? We don't know, but we need to find out.