ADVERTISEMENT

Is it better to play a QB that you develop or a hired gun?

I saw this stat and was shocked. 63.2% of starting Power 4 Qb's are transfers. Below is a small paragraph from the article with the link from CBS Sports

Of those 36 projected new starters, 27 are transfers in their first seasons with their new programs, and 20 of those come from other power conference schools. In total, 44 of the 68 expected starters have transferred at some point in their careers. https://www.cbssports.com/college-f...-qb-by-class-star-rating-and-transfer-status/

Watching some of the games since Saturday, there seems to be some sputtering in QB play. Is it from transferring, trying to learn the new system or are they that bad? I would think you want to develop the O-line the most, but a very close second is the QB. Is the roulette wheel of QB's beginning to hurt the play on the field? Watching Miller last night from NDSU, who they developed, played a smart game and stayed within himself because he knew the system. Sanders looked skiddish and unsure of his protection. The Minn and UNC was flat out bad, and the QB from NC State looked out of sync all night.

What are your thoughts?

Stolen from Reddit

HentaiHerbie


Chasing 3 - Dylan doesn't have to be good, he just has to not suck​



Maybe expectations are something that we can think about in a rational way. It is surprising to me that expectations and hype feel very moderated around the Huskersphere, especially compared to some periods in the Scott Frost era. This is probably healthy, but at the same time, I think people need to remember that Matt Rhule matched Scott Frost's best record in season one behind some of the worst QB play that a terrible QB school has ever had to endure. Plus 5-star Dylan Raiola is coming in despite Scott Frost's best efforts to keep him away from Lincoln.

Dylan doesn't have to be great, he just has to not suck​

All offseason, Nebraska has been putting out content that they are Chasing 3 in reference to their 5 losses by one score (stop me if you have heard this one before). But does anyone remember just what level those quarterbacks (none of whom will be starting in college this year despite eligibility) played at last year in those #onescorelosses? Let's look:

Minnesota: L 10-13​

  • Jeff Simms
  • 11 Comp, 19 Att, 114 yards (57.9%)
  • 1 TD, 3 INT, 3 Sacks
  • 94.1 QBR

Michigan State: L 17-20​

  • Heinrich Haarberg
  • 12 Comp, 28 Att, 129 yards (42.9%)
  • 0 TD, 2 INT, 7 Sacks
  • 67.3 QBR

Maryland: L 10-13​

  • Jeff Simms, Chubba Purdy, Heinrich Haarberg
  • 10 Comp, 21 Att, 86 yards (47.6%)
  • 0 TD, 4 INT, 1 Sacks
  • 67.3 QBR

Wisconsin: L 17-24 (OT)​

  • Chubba Purdy
  • 15 Comp, 24 Att, 169 yards (62.5%)
  • 1 TD, 1 INT, 2 Sacks
  • 127.1 QBR

Iowa: L 10-13​

  • Chubba Purdy
  • 15 Comp, 28 Att, 189 yards (53.6%)
  • 1 TD, 1 INT, 3 Sacks
  • 114.9 QBR

One Score Losses Averages:​

  • Jeff Simms, Chubba Purdy, Heinrich Haarberg
  • 12.6 Comp, 24.0 Att, 137.4 yards (52.5%)
  • 0.6 TD, 2.2 INT, 3.2 Sacks
  • 90.5 QBR

So like those don't seem great, but how bad are they?​

So like I said, Dylan doesn't have to be great, he just has to not suck. For comparison across the whole 2023 CFB season, here is where the Nebraska QB room would have ranked nationally:
  • Completion %: 122nd (their actual ranking!)
  • Passing Yards: 127th (actually better than their season long ranking and average!)
  • Yards/Attempt: 127th
  • QBR: 134th (there were only 133 teams)
So what would dead average look like?
  • Dylan Raiola
  • 19.1 Comp, 31.4 Att, 221.6 yards (60.81%)
  • 2.0 TD, 0.8 INT, 2.0 Sacks
  • 133.6 QBR
In short, he does not have to be a hero day one, and I think it is important that we all keep that in mind. I think he will be amazing, but there will be some roadbumps.

Recruiting Four-star LB Christian Jones returning to Nebraska Saturday

2025 Omaha Westside four-star LB Christian Jones had no visits set when I talked to him last night, but he texted me this evening saying he’s now planning to drive down to Lincoln to see Nebraska kick off the season against UTEP

Critical month in the in-state standout’s recruitment. Likely won’t be the only trip he makes to Lincoln this month, Nebraska would love to get him back down next week

Login to view embedded media
ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT