ADVERTISEMENT

OT- DC commercial plane and Blackhawk collide

Unfortunately found out this weekend that a very nice lady I know lost her daughter in the DC crash. Very bright young woman. Incredibly sad situation as she saw the breaking news on television and knew her daughter was on the flight.
Yeah that's rough 😕 😞 😔
 
Unfortunately found out this weekend that a very nice lady I know lost her daughter in the DC crash. Very bright young woman. Incredibly sad situation as she saw the breaking news on television and knew her daughter was on the flight.
Ya that has to horrible.
 
Unfortunately found out this weekend that a very nice lady I know lost her daughter in the DC crash. Very bright young woman. Incredibly sad situation as she saw the breaking news on television and knew her daughter was on the flight.
horrible. We have to get to the bottom of all the contributing factors and eliminate them so nothing like this happens again.
 
We refine their oil for them since they don't have the refineries

There was nothing vague. And you can make improvements in protocol, but it doesn't change where the responsibility of this lies.

Helicopters shouldn't be running missions in Class B, C or D airspace. Absolving the military of this is supporting them continuing this insanity.
Where did I say I’m absolving the military? Hence, there wasn’t a single point of failure. I’m guessing you’ve never flown. Do you have the CRJ insight, and directions to follow that traffic when there was a plane taking off, at night, is absolutely not clear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dinglefritz
Where did I say I’m absolving the military? Hence, there wasn’t a single point of failure. I’m guessing you’ve never flown. Do you have the CRJ insight, and directions to follow that traffic when there was a plane taking off, at night, is absolutely not clear.
It must have been clear to the helicopter because they never asked for clarification.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bruce1981
This is probably a little above your level, so try to stay with me. Your guy is upset because we have a trade deficit with Canada. Why do we have a trade deficit? Because we need the resources they have for our economy. We absolutely need to get along with them.
When is the last time the US had a trade surplus with Canada? What existing tariffs that Canada has on US goods are the good ones that make the trade relationship a good one?
 
Well that changes a lot of narratives if true.

It’s not completely true and his statement is disingenuous at best. May have already been stated but they have not recovered the flight recorder from the chopper. Flight recorders are considered the most accurate and reliable measure of altitude, speed etc… The flight recorder on the air jet says it was at 325 feet when it struck the helicopter. Now… The records from the air traffic control tower say the helicopter was at 200 ft. So currently there is a 125 foot discrepancy between the plane’s flight data recorder and the tower records. The gov’t has yet to provide an explanation for this 125 foot discrepancy and is waiting for the flight data from the blackhawk to hopefully clear things up.

Remember, the flight data recorder is considered the most accurate record available.
 
Last edited:
This is probably a little above your level, so try to stay with me. Your guy is upset because we have a trade deficit with Canada. Why do we have a trade deficit? Because we need the resources they have for our economy. We absolutely need to get along with them.
Lmao. Canada will cave to whatever he wants.
Regardless, you believe tariffs are good for the US? Just trying to figure out where some of you stand.
Every country tariffs the hell out of us. Canada tariffs the hell out of us. It’s sad the media lies for foreign interests and we have citizens so daft because of it that they hate their country. The entire media complex is guilty of treason
 
It must have been clear to the helicopter because they never asked for clarification.
Yeah. It’s was perfectly clear to the helo. They saw the inbound CRJ and the pilot said, hold my beer, check this shit out and ran right into it. That makes perfect sense.
 
Yeah. It’s was perfectly clear to the helo. They saw the inbound CRJ and the pilot said, hold my beer, check this shit out and ran right into it. That makes perfect sense.
No it was perfectly clear they saw the wrong plane . They were asked multiple times even once after receiving visual separation. They answered affirmative every time. This is totally on the helicopter flight crew . But you and Dingle won’t accept that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: meo1960
But in very very few instance has it ever produced a net positive result. China has made us very wealthy too. You really think these American industries want to pay the wages and prices associated with production of some of the goods that chinese companies do for them at pennies on the dollar? Who's going to foot that bill in the end? The very people who voted to lower prices in the first place. Makes no sense. Yet it does when we look at the history of the person making the decisions.
totally! I so wish that you were in charge and making these decisions than that dumb dumb who ran this country into the ground last time around and doesn't have any business experience at all. Cavalot 2028!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HBK4life
Stop trying to argue left and right politics and border security etc.

This thread is about the crash only from here on out. If you have anything to add to that great. If not, don't even post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Charlie Marlow
interest smiling GIF
 
No it was perfectly clear they saw the wrong plane . They were asked multiple times even once after receiving visual separation. They answered affirmative every time. This is totally on the helicopter flight crew . But you and Dingle won’t accept that.
I accept it. This disaster also uncovered other problems that have to be corrected as well. Controller staffing, helicopter routes, helicopter full crews, night vision use in that corridor, etc. Change any of these variables and even with a chopper at that elevation, this collision maybe doesn’t happen. As somebody else pointed out, problems like the traffic in that area don’t get fixed until something like this happens.
 
I accept it. This disaster also uncovered other problems that have to be corrected as well. Controller staffing, helicopter routes, helicopter full crews, night vision use in that corridor, etc. Change any of these variables and even with a chopper at that elevation, this collision maybe doesn’t happen. As somebody else pointed out, problems like the traffic in that area don’t get fixed until something like this happens.
Unfortunately your last statement is true . With all the near misses hope was they would correct things before something like this happened. My major sticking point with you on this was when you brought up the AA pilot and possibly his part . He was the ONLY one including the Helicopter pilot that played no part in this tragic event. Hopefully this never happens again.
 
I accept it. This disaster also uncovered other problems that have to be corrected as well. Controller staffing, helicopter routes, helicopter full crews, night vision use in that corridor, etc. Change any of these variables and even with a chopper at that elevation, this collision maybe doesn’t happen. As somebody else pointed out, problems like the traffic in that area don’t get fixed until something like this happens.
Of course if they change the route the elevation wouldn't matter. There is a very distinct reason there is a 200 foot ceiling right there. It's right in front of a runway. If you were to download autopylot and go to eppley there are 50 foot ceilings for drones following the radius of the airport and it increases as you go out. I live in a 400 foot ceiling. If I go 3/4 a mild southwest, it drops to 200 feet. If I breach that 200 foot ceiling and get caught, with no damage to anything I could face a 10,000 dollar fine and 6 months in jail. For breaching the ceiling with a less than half pound drone the size of a small plate.

There doesn't need to be any training by helicopters in that airspace. Period. Ever again.
 
Unfortunately your last statement is true . With all the near misses hope was they would correct things before something like this happened. My major sticking point with you on this was when you brought up the AA pilot and possibly his part . He was the ONLY one including the Helicopter pilot that played no part in this tragic event. Hopefully this never happens again.
He was in fact a very young and inexperienced pilot as I had suggested he might be. IF he had more experience maybe he would have been more aware of the potential for helicopter cross traffic to be watching for. Maybe if he’s flying a newer jet maybe there’s better accident avoidance technology available to him. He made no prosecutable errors. The controller supervisor for letting the helicopter controller leave early is a concern for me. Multiple people have questioned that move in this particular airspace. The commander that allowed that Blackhawk crew to go out short handed should be questioned. That route in the middle of the river while approved was ridiculous. They have to look at the entire situation. 😕. None of it brings those people back including the chopper crew.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT