ADVERTISEMENT

CharMar Brown. RB

Because he is 20 months removed from being basically unrecruited by every power 4/5 team in the country. He sits out a year, then is one of 2 running backs, a team with a running QB, on the FCS national championship team. They played in 16 games and while his 244 carries and 1181 yards looks impressive, it is literally 15 carries for 73 yards per game and 4.8 ypc. Emmitt Johnson in the last 3 games of the regular season and the bowl game rushed for 314 yards on 59 carries 5.3 ypc. In the last 4 games, the FCS playoffs, Brown had 55 carries for 216 yards, 3.93 ypc and 1 TD.

I don't necessarily have anything against this player, I just don't believe he is the difference between 7-6 and 9-4. I definitely do not believe he is worth getting into a bidding war. And if he wasn't a local kid, no one on the forum would be concerned at all about this guy. Everyone on here, myself included, complains about not winning games yet when it comes down to picking up a transfer player or a HS recruit, it appears it is more important to overpay for a local player than to go all in on a national recruit.
Well said Taco.
 
Barthel comes in for a lot abuse here and of course several board members like to be snide about Rhule, but as I’ve wondered through the comments, Holgerson is absent. I’m sure Dana would be pushing to get to the front of the line on this kid if he thought the RB room was shaky and this kid would be a substantial add. He apparently doesn’t.
 
There indeed may be budget constraints.. we blew our wad it seems:





just to add, this I don't think includes NIL? I am not sure.. maybe the current regime is raping the program, I don't know what conclusions to draw from this.

Wait, what? We're outspending Ohio State by almost $5.5M? And we still have that big of a talent disparity? Yikes, if true.

Only conclusions to draw are...
  1. We've got way too many eggs in one, or a handful of small baskets. Meaning we're paying one or a handful of guys way too much with not enough left for other positions. Dylan?
  2. Our talent evaluation sucks. I thought that was supposed to be one of Rhule's big strengths. Finding diamonds in the rough and all that.
  3. We're having to overpay just to get players to NU. That might be a harsh reality until we're back to being relevant again, I guess.
 
If EJ wasn’t hired at Nebraska, Ives would be at Monmouth right now and no P 4/5 offers. And correct me if I’m wrong but Nelson would have taken a post grad year at a prep school with no P 4/5 offers. The staff might like those two but they are very unproven backs in their own right. And Brown now has more P 4/5 offers then those two

And for those that say they like Ives. Kid has 7 yards on 6 attempts. And that includes 4 yards on 3 rushes against UTEP the #102 rushing defense in the nation last year. It’s not crazy that Husker fans don’t have a lot of faith in him. All our other backs ran well in that game. Maybe he’s changed or maybe EJ is willing to die on the hill. Time will tell
I like EJ. He's a nice back. The problem is that Barthel and Rhule have spent the last 2 years trying not to play him. So, how much do they really love him? I'll believe Ives is the real deal when I see it. I think Booth had or is having surgery? So Parker is going to have to be ready and stay healthy.

That is my main interest in Brown. He's at least been through a full season of CFB, and played well enough to attract a list of suitors.
 
So you think Brown is a can't miss prospect?
Definitely not a can't miss prospect, but a very intriguing prospect. He held up for an entire season through the playoffs, but is also a freshman. So, one could assume he has room for improvement. IMO we are 2 deep at rb, EJ and Parker. Neither has held up to an entire season of carries as the main rb in college. Brown would be a nice insurance policy. A nice, young, insurance policy.
 
Definitely not a can't miss prospect, but a very intriguing prospect. He held up for an entire season through the playoffs, but is also a freshman. So, one could assume he has room for improvement. IMO we are 2 deep at rb, EJ and Parker. Neither has held up to an entire season of carries as the main rb in college. Brown would be a nice insurance policy. A nice, young, insurance policy.
Would you pay more to get Brown than EJ is currently getting?
 
Because he is 20 months removed from being basically unrecruited by every power 4/5 team in the country. He sits out a year, then is one of 2 running backs, a team with a running QB, on the FCS national championship team. They played in 16 games and while his 244 carries and 1181 yards looks impressive, it is literally 15 carries for 73 yards per game and 4.8 ypc. Emmitt Johnson in the last 3 games of the regular season and the bowl game rushed for 314 yards on 59 carries 5.3 ypc. In the last 4 games, the FCS playoffs, Brown had 55 carries for 216 yards, 3.93 ypc and 1 TD.

I don't necessarily have anything against this player, I just don't believe he is the difference between 7-6 and 9-4. I definitely do not believe he is worth getting into a bidding war. And if he wasn't a local kid, no one on the forum would be concerned at all about this guy. Everyone on here, myself included, complains about not winning games yet when it comes down to picking up a transfer player or a HS recruit, it appears it is more important to overpay for a local player than to go all in on a national recruit.
We need help at RB

Which national prospect should we be going all in on?

Cupboard is bare, so is the portal
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huskers123456
We need help at RB

Which national prospect should we be going all in on?

Cupboard is bare, so is the portal
For now Ives seems like he has taken a step up from last season and we don’t really know yet about Parker and Booth development.

I wouldn’t say our running back room is completely bare.
 
For now Ives seems like he has taken a step up from last season and we don’t really know yet about Parker and Booth development.

I wouldn’t say our running back room is completely bare.

Seems like a lot of guys take a step up from last season in the off season every year.
 
For now Ives seems like he has taken a step up from last season and we don’t really know yet about Parker and Booth development.

I wouldn’t say our running back room is completely bare.
I’ll believe it when I see it re: Ives.

We need better if we’re going to gain 800 more yards on the ground this year like Tuco says (will also believe that when I see it).
 
I’ll believe it when I see it re: Ives.

We need better.
I believe that Rhule has given Holgersen carte blanche with regards to the offense. He was able to eventually rid himself of McGuire as WR coach and bring in his own guy. If he wanted to bring in another RB he would have, especially after losing Ervin and Dowdell to the portal.
 
I believe that Rhule has given Holgersen carte blanche with regards to the offense. He was able to eventually rid himself of McGuire as WR coach and bring in his own guy. If he wanted to bring in another RB he would have, especially after losing Ervin and Dowdell to the portal.
800 more rush yards this year?

Believe that when I see it, too. Even with our cakewalk schedule.

This will be a season where we learn if Dana has discipline required to commit to the run or if he can’t help himself & we throw throw throw (my expectation).
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT