State basketball tournament
- Thread starter Charlie Marlow
- Start date
Who’s the highest rated boy of any grade playing in the tournament not already committed to a P5 school, Dotzler? Matt A. stay back to watch?
I would watch more if they put in a shot clock. Too many games with final scores in the 30s and 40s. I'd rather watch paint dry than whatever that is Auburn and Beatrice call basketball.
They should also make private schools play up a class. Put Skutt in Class A, Kearney Catholic and GICC in Class B, etc.
not that Im against it, but why? Because they can recruit? Most schools recruit these days.
I think it's more that while recruiting they can control their enrollment too. Keeping them at lower classifications while getting the better athletes. As opposed to public schools having to accept any student in their school district.
Amherst playing Grand Island CC in Class C2 at State is fair to you?
Maybe I' wrong, but I highly doubt anybody from Kearney is willingly travelling to Amherst to attend high school.
they really dont though. They only have to accept those within their home school zone. Everything else is based on availability. So lets use Omaha Central as an (really bad) example. They only have to accept kids within their home zone. If my kid wanted to go there, it would only be based on open availability. So theorhetically, if OPS wanted them to be Class B, they could just restrict the number of out of zone kids they let in.
I say Omaha Central is a bad example, as I think they are one of the largest schools in the state.
I agree with what you're saying concerning the metro schools. The bigger problem is with smaller towns like Kearney, Hastings, Norfolk, GI, Columbus and especially smaller towns than those where they have both public and parochial/private schools. The private schools can recruit the kids they want, keep their numbers down and let the public schools get the rest. In the small towns you go to school in your school district or opt in to a school out of your district.
That's why a lot of these smaller parochial/private schools are perennial powers across multiple sports. They try to get the best kids they can, while keeping enrollment down, yet are good enough to play in a higher class than what they are.
But why would they turn away paying customers to keep numbers down?
It's being able to recruit and also not having to take all the other students, including all the special-needs students. So private schools have a higher percentage of athletes in their enrollment. Public schools have to accept everyone.
Do you honest think it's fair for Falls City Sacred Heart and Lincoln Parkview Christian to be in the same class as Hyannis and Wynot, which are towns of less than 200 people? For North Platte St Pat's to be in the same class as Loomis, population 400? Grand Island Catholic in the same class as Amherst, population 250?
Skutt and Roncalli both won by about 25 points in semifinal games today....why don't they step up to class A and play against other Omaha schools, instead of dominating small-town public schools?
So private schools are deliberately suppressing enrollment and intentionally foregoing hundreds of thousands of dollars in annual tuition revenue in the hope that their athletic team can achieve a competitive advantage? Lay off the weed for a while.
vested parental interest
better athletic programs, apparently
Amen...and that is something that any parent can do.
Look at Prep...they have been lame AF in football and basketball the last 20 years...but but but they are private!!!!
You telling me Norfolk Catholic doesn't offer a better high school education and athletics opportunity in Class C2 Nebraska than Amherst, Wakefield, and Freeman?
Of course private schools recruit students. It is an absolute necessity because private institutions are not financially supported or funded by state government They need students to enroll and pay tuition and other fees so that, along with fundraising, they can maintain financial viability. .Anyone objecting to such a practice is an idiot.
Last edited:
When you say “most” I’m assuming that you’re talking about Omaha/Lincoln metro and ignoring the rest of the state.
The people at Norfolk Catholic would say they provide a better High School education. From what I know, it’s not a given.
I spent a few years with an organization that provided scholarships to all three schools in Norfolk. There was nothing that stood out with Norfolk Catholic’s curriculum.
You are 100% correct heck even several priests said the same thing, they don’t recruit as much as controlling the enrollment. Fall City sacred hearts a classic example
Nah.
Show me how an Amherst HS student gets as good an education as a Norfolk Catholic kid.
This is exactly why Amherst is C2. They're pulling in some kids from Kearney.
I think you're the one claiming one is better than the other. The burden of proof falls to you my friend.
Another reason why private schools in the smaller classes have built in advantages is money. They can afford more lessons, supplements, equipment, etc.
As others stated, this doesn't have much effect on Omaha/Lincoln Class A schools however...
As others stated, this doesn't have much effect on Omaha/Lincoln Class A schools however...
Last edited:
You're right. A town of 250 is class C2 all on their own...
They don't pull a lot from Kearney, but a few Kearney kids do go to Amherst.
Your hypothetical projection is false. Just because you brainstorm reasons why rhey are successful or parrot talking points you heard doesnt mean this actually happens. Because it doesnt. “Control their enrollment” and keep out the unathletic…my goodness what an absolute crock.
Dont say things you dont actually know. Thats quite an accusation
,
Similar threads
