I don't think any aac coaches have had any success in power 5. Fickell didn't do well at osu even with the talent advantage.
But yet at Cincinnati he's ranked in the top 5 at #2 and has quality wins against Indiana and Notre Dame. Do I believe Cincy deserves a #2 spot? No. The thing is, he's solid and has put in the work at a place it's even tougher to recruit. I don't see being interim coach at Ohio State as a good read, his statement of work starts at Cincy in 2017.
2017 = 4-8
2018 = 11-2, beat UCLA and VT (Bowl game), ranked 19th
2019 = 11-3, beat UCLA and BC (Bowl game), ranked 17th
2020 = 9-1, Covid year, lost to
Georgia 24-21 in bowl game, ranked 6th
2021 = 8-?, beat Indiana and Notre Dame so far, currently ranked 2nd with a possible playoff birth.
What's our record since 2017 and what quality wins can you point out in comparison. Sure Fickle plays in a weaker conference but he beats who he's suppose to plus bigger schools. What if Nebraska played Cincy schedule this year, would we be able to accomplish the same? We might beat the in conference teams but would have lost to Indiana and Notre Dame. If we threw Cincy on that schedule we'd lose to them also.