ADVERTISEMENT

The College Football Playoff needs to expand

Why do people insist on taking college football, the greatest sports category in existence, built on being unique. Built on having a regular season that matters. And try to change it into something that resembles a lesser sport? The nfl sucks. The nfl has 32 teams. The nfl has parity. Those things don’t exist in college football. There is no way to make college football resemble the nfl in format. And we shouldn’t want it to. The debates, controversy and flawed system have made college football what it is. Stop trying to change it and embrace it. Everything they’ve done has made it worse. 12 teams is stupid. Oregon already beat Ohio State, Penn state and Boise. Georgia already beat Texas. End this. Give us Georgia vs Oregon, winner take all. Make the regular season great again.
Ive never understood it either.

“Hey! This college football stuff is great and unique! Lets change it.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bruce1981
Ohio state already lost to Oregon. Why do they get another shot? If you’re better, win the first time. Rematches in college football are stupid. Who did Ohio state play that Oregon didn’t? Indiana? Pft. Who cares? Make the regular season matter. They already played. Oregon won. You shouldn’t get a do over. Add to that Oregon is undefeated. Beat 3 quarter final teams. And Ohio state lost to Michigan. They blew it. I don’t care who would be favored in a single game. I care about who showed up every week and handled their business. Oregon did. Ohio state didn’t. This system of 12 teams does little to reward that.
Exactly. Had ohio state beat michigan, oregon would have had to beat ohio state three times possibly to win the natty. Absolutely stupid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bruce1981
That wasn’t your model, imbecile.
dumb ass, the B1G and sec need to sheet, piss or get off the pot...this slow grind to 2 conferances is foul at best...if you want the 2 conferance mini nfl...then do it allready....and save all the beeecthing...and wasting folks time...
 
dumb ass, the B1G and sec need to sheet, piss or get off the pot...this slow grind to 2 conferances is foul at best...if you want the 2 conferance mini nfl...then do it allready....and save all the beeecthing...and wasting folks time...
Your incoherent, subliterate rambling is tiresome. You’re arguing with your own submoronic imagination.
 
12 was stupid but it was clearly just to "get it started"

These first round games were amazing even though they sucked. They are going to go to 16, it is going to be ****ing awesome and it is going to become a huge gambling thing like March Madness.
It's gonna blow. It's gonna be for casuals and gambling degenerates.
 
most years, college football only needs two teams. Oregon vs Georgia is all we needed this year.
There is a very good chance neither of those teams makes it past the next round, especially Georgia. The playoff is working even if there are some early blowouts and the seeding needs to be based on the final ranking, not conf championships.
I would expand it to 16 teams with no byes, and quite honestly we ought to just drop conf championship games. The teams with the best record in their massive conferences are the champions. Why do we need to potentially see Georgia-Texas a third time, and Georgia's starting QB was injured playing in a conf championship. With the playoff in place those extra games just do more harm than good
 
Why did Penn State have to play Nebraska again in the Final Four? Penn State beat them 3-1 a few weeks ago, did they really need to have a rematch?

After the Final Four was set, Nebraska should had to forfeit since they already lost to Penn State. Sorry, you lost at their place, you don't get a rematch at a neutral site when the stakes are higher.
If you are talking about reducing the number of teams that get into the volleyball tournament and changing the selection process then your logic would make sense. But as it is you are comparing apples to oranges.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scarletred
Conferences all want the chance to get a taste of playoff dough. Most years the last 3-4 teams aren’t going to be particularly competitive, but they can hang a playoff banner. The expanded playoff number plus the reality of the transfer portal should produce more competitive play in these first games in the coming years. It’s just going to be harder for the top teams to hoard talent.
 
Season 5 No GIF by The Office
 
I have always thought 8 was the right amount of teams. Either that or 16 because teams having a bye while the other team plays a top caliber opponent is an unfair advantage. The reason I think 8 is better than 16 is because realistically, there aren't 16 teams with a chance to win in it all. Usually on 3 or 4 but if you start with 8 you could still have the conference champions, whether its 4 or when it was 5, plus have room for a couple of at large bids for a Cinderella and those excellent teams. The seedings this year were completely stupid. Does anyone really believe that Boise or ASU are deserving of a top seed and bye in the first round?
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuskerO
Conferences all want the chance to get a taste of playoff dough. Most years the last 3-4 teams aren’t going to be particularly competitive, but they can hang a playoff banner. The expanded playoff number plus the reality of the transfer portal should produce more competitive play in these first games in the coming years. It’s just going to be harder for the top teams to hoard talent.
For some reason i get the feeling that the rich will get richer they will find away around the 105 and hoard more top players
 
So it takes 3 weeks for the NCAA basketball tournament to finish..

It’s going to take 4 weeks to finish the CFP. Football has more game planning from one opponent to the next not to mention the physicality of the game alone..

Basketball tournament plays two games with in 4 days and there is one day to prepare for the next game.

Expanding CFP is ridiculous.
 
So it takes 3 weeks for the NCAA basketball tournament to finish..

It’s going to take 4 weeks to finish the CFP. Football has more game planning from one opponent to the next not to mention the physicality of the game alone..

Basketball tournament plays two games with in 4 days and there is one day to prepare for the next game.

Expanding CFP is ridiculous.
Going from 12 to 16 won’t add another round/week

Anything more than that obviously will
 
Going from 12 to 16 won’t add another round/week

Anything more than that obviously will
Still takes a month to play it, more games more of a chance for key players getting injury’s making more difficult to move on winning the championship.

16 teams would allow more 3 loss teams involved that DEI.
Reason why the regular season should mean something..

Just because the NFL has 9-8 team making the playoffs doesn’t mean CPF needs 16 teams.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT