True. But he based his comments on recent firings and the short attention span of recruits. Not a lot of deep coaching analysis in those comments. I actually find Cowherd's arguments as compelling. All of those reasons are valid and make it more challenging for Nebraska. At the same time, Nebraska has a strong commitment to success, a great fan base and player experience, great facilities, weak division, and rich tradition (which means something to some of the coaches, if not many recruits). And both Callahan and Riley have now proven that you can recruit elite talent to Nebraska. You just have to have elite recruiters and work harder than most places.
well I don't find CC compelling, but to each their own.
A non-nebraskan, and not a dipstick like CC, would look at the following in what you consider a 'weak' division...
great facilities (training facilities) - check, but where does it really rank in comparison to Iowa (Dinardo's favorite in the B1G), NW (are you kidding me, new and state of the art overlooking Lake Michigan), Wisconsin (actually showing its age some), Purdue (currently building), Minnesota (currently building), Illinois (currently building). NU is on the brink of having the oldest training facilities in the West.
great facilities(stadium)- check. Camp Randall, Kinnick, the thing in the twin cities are all different, but pretty cool - purely subjective on how a non-nebraskan or outsider, like Belotti, would rank.
great fan base - check. Same for wisconsin and Iowa. Although ours is acting like big babies right now and despite proclaiming to be teh best inteh land, it's a hard place for player crticism
Strong Commitment to success - see facilities and coaches. Ferentz=like it or not is almost certainly a hall of fame coach closing in on B1G records for wins. Wisky = PC is good. Ill= a super bowl coach, PU=wow, what a job that guy is doing. NW=has a rep and offers stability, Minn=clown
player experience - academics vs the rest of the west, ah nope. NFL preparedness- line up behind Iowa and Wisky for the past decade or two. Critique by fans...we're in a class by our self.
Rich Tradition - check. However, the most National titles in the West...I think that's Minnesota. Most recent BCS caliber games, again behind Wisky and Iowa. QBs, that's Purdue. Heck, even the Heisman's likeness of of an Illinois player. The whole conference drips in tradition, and each team is proud of theirs.
You didn't list money - push. The B1G and BTN have leveled the playing field.
Proximity to recruits. We're the outpost, with the smallest surrounding population. Next is Iowa who shares another D1 school, but the state has twice the population of Neb. They are 3 hour drive from Chicago, with in 4 and half hours to Minneapolis, KC, St. Louis.
My whole point is things are competitive, winning is harder than it use to be, all other things are pretty subjective....thus, I see what Belotti is getting at.
And, Nebraska needs a really good coach to combat all of these reasons.