Lots of guys get plum jobs that cannot win. Look at the coaches Florida had prior to him, and after....Urban, in addition to being an amazing coach, is smart to take the jobs he took at the time he did...that is a point in his favor IMO... Urban is one of the best college coaches ever. 100% Grade A slimeball, but behind only Saban IMO as the greatest CFB coach....then I'd put our very own T.O. at 3rd...YMMV
Kinda along your and Dean's comments, but Saban probably could have coached at Michigan State for 25 years and never got a whiff of a national title.
Meyer took over a Utah team coming off a 5-6 season and in year one went 10-2 and in year 2 went 12-0. No doubt, that sob can really coach. TO, without a doubt had a more difficult situation than either Saban at Bama or Meyer at Florida or Ohio State.
Scant population among the biggest reasons, but I "think" at one time, I tallied it up and TO won 3 national titles, but also played for or was beaten by the eventual national champion about 10 times in his career. It might have been (not gonna check) the same year that NU was beaten by both Colorado and Georgia Tech who were co-national champions that year.
Then of course, Oklahoma several times, Miami, Clemson, Florida State, robbed at Penn Stae even though Ga beat them for the title. Dude had a lot of bad luck for a lot of years.
Again, off the top of my head, but TO was so close so many times it makes you wonder what his teams might have accomplished in a 25 year career at Bama or Florida with their built in recruiting advantages.
I can't argue against Saban being the greatest ever and Urban the second best.