He hasn't been in Lincoln three full years yet. This is his third season coaching the team. He was trying to hold a class together in winter 2014-15, which they did a decent job of all things considered. So now he has had two classes, and this will be his third in January 2018. He added one of the most savage recruiters in the country last winter to partner with one we already have, and we have a few other coaches that are doing some pretty good things. We are in on so many guys. Just because you don't think you see results doesn't mean its not happening. I wouldn't look to Rivals recruiting stars to base your evaluation of signed classes on.
But, FFS, he's really only had two full classes to recruit...those guys are true freshmen and redshirt freshmen/true sophomores this year. You don't build a 10 or 11 win season on the backs of freshmen and sophomores. A lot of them are playing or are on the two deep. He went out and got us a QB that can throw the ball...save your QB evaluation. Dude can spin it. Based on who was available for him to go get, he went and got one of the best options available. Otherwise, we're starting a redshirt freshman at QB and probably not able to redshirt the latest QB recruit who will likely be the best of the three.
Pelini left us with a house of cards, and we saw it come crashing down a few times at the end of his tenure and also during Riley's first couple of years. The embarassing loss at Iowa last year? We were playing with a skeleton crew. I'm surprised it didn't happen sooner last year.
So restocking is going to take time. I think one thing people need to pay attention to is the talent evaluation of this staff vs the old staff of the kids that actually make it here. Recruiting site rankings might be similar, but Riley has had more freshmen and sophomores making meaningful contributions that Pelini ever had. Partly because they HAVE TO play because of Pelini's recruiting failures toward the end of his tenure (look at what the program was left with at OL and all of the misses he had on those 3 star guys. If you're looking for young guys stepping in and playing well, we had a freshman that Riley recruited just overtake a senior at RT that Pelini recruited.To me, its trending positive and will continue to trend even more positive with the next class.
On the football side of things, Pelini NEVER was able to make adjustments once teams figured out how to expose his cover 2 shell. Really, since the transition to the Big Ten required him to get out of his Cover 2 shell when teams. He stubbornly stuck to it, his kids didn't even believe they could stop the run in it at the end because they couldn't. In the Big 10, with all of the rushing attacks, they were being set up to fail. And he never changed a thing. At least this staff is showing the ability to adjust.
Pelini rarely if ever changed out underperforming staff members. And his staff was pretty crummy,. He had a QB coach who didn't know how to coach QBs, he had a golf coach coaching his WRs. WTF. Riley has made tough decisions and upgraded every off season, and he has brought in guys universally respected in the industry each time. How can you miss that?