Hindsight is always 20/20, but its difficult for me to comprehend how Rivals felt Roy was a 5.5 three star. I've been accused of being a "Stars don't matter" guy. That's not the case. However, I'm definitely in the camp of people who believe the recruiting services don't evaluate everyone fairly and consistently.
This is the film of a minimum 5.8 Four Star recruit:
This is the film of a minimum 5.8 Four Star recruit: