I'm fed up with the blame game and if we had ... What does it take to win in college football? A HC who has CHARISMA and can lure top athletes to play for them. There are very people who fit that bill, and those that have it, play for the marbles most of the time. Without top flight athletes you will not bring home any hardware.
I watched Urban Meyer climb up the ranks starting with Bowling Green and Josh Harris as the QB. From there he went to Utah with Alex Smith as his QB, then to Florida with Leak and Tebow as his QB's. Not all of his QB's were recruited by him but the man can coach QB's.
Not sold on Kelly because he inherited his team from Nike money and Bellotti. Scandals surrounding team with recruiting.
Les Miles had a +7 record at OSU and then landed in the hot bed of recruiting. Took over for Nick Saban.
Saban is just a freak of nature. There will never be another one like him.
Harbaugh is like a QB whisperer. Not to sure how long he will last on any given job, but he will win wherever he goes. He has the knack of recruiting and knows how to close.
Tom Herman, still too early to tell
Mike Riley has the character that parents want in a HC. He was +13 at OSU (6-18 since) and won 2 CFL championships, so he knows how to put together a team. I also know he has put numerous players in the league. So far he has improved the talent level since he has been here but now he needs to turn the corner. He has shown he is willing to make changes to the staff and bring in quality assistants. He inherited a floundering ship with self centered individuals who could care less about others and are uncoachable. Their play on the field reflects this.This is not going to be a fast fix or painless fix. But, switching coaches every 3-4 years will do irreparable harm that could take decades to correct. Does Riley have he charisma to lure in the top athletes? Don't know, only time will tell.I prefer a coach like MR over a Harbaugh or Herman who will always be looking for greener pastures.