ADVERTISEMENT

Malachi Coleman

I have zero insights into any the level of truth behind the internet fodder on Coleman's desire or commitment to play. However, I don't envy Rhule or any coach for that matter, who has to wrestle with how hard they are going to pursue signing the top recruit in this state if there truly are non-talent concerns involved. The fear of the PR backlash of not doing so probably trumps all else.
 
Wish the kid well. Seems like a good kid, maybe he will thrive at the G5 or lower level.
Skills wise, I did not see him anywhere near a polished P4 WR.

We do however, need to get one in the portal for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dean Pope
I have zero insights into any the level of truth behind the internet fodder on Coleman's desire or commitment to play. However, I don't envy Rhule or any coach for that matter, who has to wrestle with how hard they are going to pursue signing the top recruit in this state if there truly are non-talent concerns involved. The fear of the PR backlash of not doing so probably trumps all else.

I can’t imagine any major P4 coach not recruiting the #1 player in their state. I don’t have the numbers on this, but I’m willing to bet that 80% of top players (state) end up being highly productive D1 players. (If I’m off on that then feel free to show me) Sucks that Coleman didn’t pan out, maybe he will elsewhere, but that doesn’t mean recruiting him was a mistake. You almost have to recruit the #1 player in your state.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kakdawg and WHCSC
I can’t imagine any major P4 coach not recruiting the #1 player in their state. I don’t have the numbers on this, but I’m willing to bet that 80% of top players (state) end up being highly productive D1 players. (If I’m off on that then feel free to show me) Sucks that Coleman didn’t pan out, maybe he will elsewhere, but that doesn’t mean recruiting him was a mistake. You almost have to recruit the #1 player in your state.


Was Emmett Johnson the number 1 player in Minnesota? I think he was Gatorade POY maybe. I don't think he was offered from Minnesota. Could be wrong tho...


Holla
 
Wish the kid well. Seems like a good kid, maybe he will thrive at the G5 or lower level.
Skills wise, I did not see him anywhere near a polished P4 WR.

We do however, need to get one in the portal for sure.
Heard this long ago and it may be true in this case... some kids don't have a Power Five mentality. I think going down a level would do him some good.
 
Was Emmett Johnson the number 1 player in Minnesota? I think he was Gatorade POY maybe. I don't think he was offered from Minnesota. Could be wrong tho...

Holla
I think he was rated #1 in Minnesota by somebody. Can't remember. And he was getting some looks from other places-- maybe Iowa State, for sure some MAC schools. He had great stats in HS, broke a lot of long runs. When he signed, I told myself this was just another late filler to the class-- a Pelini and Frost special. Well, I have been wrong ever since. I remember watching him play against Michigan last year. He was getting something out of nothing. He sold me then. He's been our best back ever since. Now it's obvious to everybody.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT