Cignetti

[king_kong_]

Dude we just witnessed #3 SEC vs #3 B1G.

Who cares about top sec teams racking up wins against bottom feeders like Wake Forest, FSU, UCLA, Wisky, NC state etc.

Most wins vs other p4 conferences

Most draft picks

Best teams, best players, best conference

Super simple.

I agree whole heartedly with your post that rooting for conferences is the lamest thing anyone can do.

 

[leodisflowers]

I think we can all agree that the ACC should not be included in anything.

 

[TampaBaySkers]

I think we can all agree that the ACC should not be included in anything.

Let AI pick the 12. Not Google AI though.. it would be all HBCUs

 

[leodisflowers]

Let AI pick the 12. Not Google AI though.. it would be all HBCUs

I agree. Or go back to a BCS type ranking for the 12 and that is the seeding as well. Committees are just dumb at this point to me, especially when they never answer questions or give you any info. Leave possibly 1 human element in, but that is about it.

 

[dinglefritz]

Name IU’s best win
Then go thru Alabama’s.
They have 4 quality wins compared to IU’s …? I’ll give them Michigan

Alabama beat the 2 seed
IU looked like IU in each game vs tournament teams

Shouldn’t matter. Neither deserved to be in a playoff. They lost in the season qualifying rounds.

 

[dinglefritz]

I agree. Or go back to a BCS type ranking for the 12 and that is the seeding as well. Committees are just dumb at this point to me, especially when they never answer questions or give you any info. Leave possibly 1 human element in, but that is about it.

Top 8. No byes. Screw the 12 team playoff. They already play too many games.

 

[HuskerAlum92]

Top 8. No byes. Screw the 12 team playoff. They already play too many games.

I felt 8 was the right number for a long time. I was surprised when they went straight from 4 to 12. With the money involved, it’s hard to get the toothpaste back in the bottle.

But swap Boise and ASU into first round, and everything is better. Most obvious quick fix for next year.

 

[c3o]

Shouldn’t matter. Neither deserved to be in a playoff. They lost in the season qualifying rounds.

You’re making stuff up.

 

[leodisflowers]

Top 8. No byes. Screw the 12 team playoff. They already play too many games.

I don't mind that either. I just hate this committee approach. Take them out of it.