You are missing the reference to Whipple's statement about great QBs being pricks.
Breaking...Aaron Rogers is pretty good.
- Thread starter litespeedhuskerfan
- Start date
Disagree. If Rodgers had Brady’s defenses and Belichick as HC he’d be in a similar spot. How many low scoring playoff games has Brady won? How many high scoring playoff games has Rodgers lost?
I do believe in the clutch gene but I think it gets way more credit than it deserves from many people. Rodgers has the clutch gene. He hasn’t been blessed with good defenses.
If Rodgers was the quarterback of the Bucs last night they would have won by a touchdown.
Probably by more than that.
And while Brady didn’t always have the greatest offensive weapons in New England, he sure as hell knew what roster he was choosing when moving to Tampa Bay. Evans, Godwin, Antonio, Gronk, Fournette, and an elite OL is just laughably easy. Not to mention the defense.
I’m not going to judge Brady at the age of 44 but any competent QB would’ve been the favorite to win the SB last year with that roster. Hell, Jameis Winston went .500 while throwing the most INTs in NFL history. And that’s before adding Antiono, Gronk, and Fournette.
the Bucs weren't even favorites in the actual Super Bowl game, much less for the entire season last year.
Because they underachieved all year. No reason that roster should’ve gone 11-5. IMO they would’ve had the top seed and SB victory with a handful of QBs. Given the offense around him Brady had a solid but not great season.
One of the greatest misconceptions of all time is that Rogers is winning with a bunch of C graded players. The Pack are and have had, a very good roster. Much better than the last few Brady played with in New England....and if the Bucs roster is so great and easy to win a Super Bowl with why did they suck before Brady got there with that amazing roster?
Packers haven’t had a #2 receiver since the Greg Jennings Jordy Nelson days. And more importantly their defense has been awful since the Woodson days.
And the Bucs didn’t suck before Brady. They went .500 despite their QB breaking the record for INTs in a season.
99% of the time if a QB throws 30 INTs that team is winning two games at most.
Jameis was the first 30 TD/30 INT quarterback in NFL history.
really too bad he blew out his knee this year. Saints would be legit contenders with him. super fun player to watch.
Eh they were decent with Jameis before he got hurt. They were not legit contenders.
they were 5-2 with wins over GB, @NE and TB. after Jameis went down they lost 5 straight.
does your brain publish a sportsbook? would LOVE to be on the other side of some of these opinions.
Patriots didn't have a legit #1 when Gronk walked....Rogers #1 is one of the best in the league. Every roster has a few holes, all of them. Rogers has had a very good roster for his entire careeer.
Siemien played most of the TB game.
They also lost to Carolina and the Giants with Winston. I suppose with the league being so wide open this year it’s fair to say they would’ve been contenders.
one of very few actual home field advantages in the league, defense getting better.
Jameis would've settled in, and Sean Payton wouldn't let him get too far off the fairway.
sucks Jameis got hurt - would've been a very fun addition to this year's storylines.
He has a #1 WR for sure. That doesn’t equate to “very good roster his entire career.” His defenses have been pure garbage outside of the year they won the SB.
Prior to Adams it’s debatable if Jennings and Nelson were even good receivers. They both failed after leaving GB. James Jones sucked too.
I agree Brady had lots of success with some weak receiving corps. He’s a great QB. But he also had defenses to back him up.
I hope he does, the Donkeys roster pales in comparison to the Pack and he will be facing a couple of the best QB's in the league in his own division, compared to the stiffs he gets to face in his current division every year.
Edit...I think he should stay, but I'm rooting he leaves and goes to the Bronco's because I think he'll find it much tougher sledding.
Last edited:
