Top 10 all time NFL Qbs...

[HuskerLLM]

He was surrounded with very good cast and Vice Lombardi also deserves more of the credit..

Starr was good not great…

As was Staubach with Tom L

As was Bradshaw with Chuck N

As was Montana with Bill W

Others have caught lightning in a bottle and won once...Starr had SEVEN championships, cannot be discounted

 

[bigboxes]

As was Staubach with Tom L

As was Bradshaw with Chuck N

As was Montana with Bill W

Others have caught lightning in a bottle and won once...Starr had SEVEN championships, cannot be discounted

Starr would be in the Top 20, for sure.

 

[StoneTempleHusker]

Too much comes down to players around guys, organizations, and flat talent to be honest.

I always put this as if you need to win a game and it is the 4th quarter in a tight game. I'm going with the following:

1. Tom Brady
2. John Elway
3. Peyton Manning
4. Dan Marino
5. Brett Favre
6. Joe Montana
7. Drew Brees
8. Phillip Rivers
9. Warren Moon
10. Ben Roethlisberger

 

[barney44]

Ok I’ll play( and remember, I LIKE him!)
- best coaching… check
- easiest division year after year… check check
- great defense almost every year… check
- usually Good receivers…. Sometimes GREAT ones( moss comes to mind)
- a fair degree of fortune not of his own making ( Falcons being idiots, Malcom Butler saving the game… down to 5)

Please don’t think I’m disparaging him… but it’s not as simple as “ holding a grudge”

In a team sport where titles are a factor I wouldn't say any of those things is an argument against Brady. Plenty of teams have a pretty solid roster but not every team has a franchise quarterback, the Patriots did.