Let me be clearer. Without getting into specifics of 3 or 4 players over a 20+ year run.
My main point is to say we can't afford to take these chances on the instate kids "just because" they are D1 athletes anymore. This doesn't exclude other states and regions either. Both things can be true. In state is mentioned because guys get up in arms when something like this is mentioned. They immediately go into defense mode. With 105 players u can't afford to take those chances. Each mistake costs more now.
Just because you swing and miss on a highly rated guy from Florida or California you don't stop trying to get those guys. Especially if you think you can win big with them. Because we miss on an Ott or a Phillips etc doesn't all of a sudden mean you recruit every guy with "D1 potential" to come to Nebraska. There simply isn't enough talent instate to do that...AND expect to win big with a 105 man roster.
Would you say that almost every coach at Nebraska felt pressure to win a certain way? With walk ons playing a big part? With in state guys playing a big part? With pretty much "following the wishes " of TO playing a big part?
I absolutely believe that to be the case. Good or bad I believe it's true. But the horizon has changed so much now that that formula can honestly be thrown out of a window now. A coach would never say it and I'm not even sure Matt Ruhle would think it (him Being a former walk on) but some would be relieved of not having that cloud hanging over their heads. Honestly I'm surprised Matt said what he did about the in state guys but I've thought it for a while now.
Go get the best players you can get from anywhere in the country. Supplement them with the portal and try and winnas much as you can. This year there may be 8-10 instate players with D1 offers. We MAY sign 15 HS players this year. Imagine 10 of those being in state. Do that 4 years and then expect a coach to compete for BIG championship and playoffs? I know thats a bit extreme but its basically showing how limited the numbers will be moving forward.
At some point you have to decide what it is going to take to get it done. I THINK he tried to do it one way. But has come to the conclusion that end of the day I HAVE TO WIN FIRST. Everything else HAS to be secondary. Take care of that and everything else kinda falls in place. Lose enough and you are getting fired anyways lol. So I'm gonna go out swinging in what I believe in.
Holla
You have yet to prove that past coaches have taken swings and misses on nebraska kids over national kids.
I have literally given examples of this being false…that the opposite is true, that our coaches have turned away from Nebraska kids because they are from Nebraska and frost himself signed lower ranked recruits from out of state over in state recruits. From 2018-2022, he had just 16 in state recruits. From 2023-2025, rhule had 19 commits. It is false that past coaching failures is because we chose to recruit nebraska kids instead of national recruits.
Frost in 2018: 1 of top 5 Nebraska ranked kids
2019: 5 of 5 (the one outlier)
Frost in 2020: 2 of top 5 Nebraska kids
2021: 3 of top 5
2022: 1 of top 5
Rhules 2023 class was hurt due to frosts in state efforts including a TE that is at Oklahoma.
If its coaches ignoring local kids in favor of national kids you want, you most certainly loved Frosts recruiting strategy.
In these years he went harder after players from out of state rated lower than some of ours. Coaches theoughout the state will tell you of his lack of interest in their players.
No, I dont agree that coaches felt pressure to win a certain way, if they did the facts show they didnt act on it. but every coach has and will feel pressure regardless of where it is from. I actually believe there are more people like you who look down upon nebraska recruits than people who favor them. This board alone is an indication of that.
As others have said, its only natural for any and every college to be more “in on” recruits from the general geographic area.
However, the simple facts prove that your perception that nebraska coaches of the past favored nebraska kids over national recruits is false.
I’m not currently arguing whether I agree with your preferred strategy or not, so you are shouting at the clouds. Most people just hate seeing kids going to ND, FSU, OK, Stan….
Im proving to you that the perception that past coaches recruited nebraska kids harder than national kids and that it was a contributing factor to their failures is FALSE.