ADVERTISEMENT

College Football 150 All Tme All Americans

Sorry, but there’s a couple guys on that list because of what they did after college. For instance, there is no way should Peyton Manning be the 2nd team QB.
Jerry Rice was the first person I thought of that definitely shouldn’t have been on this list. Best NFL WR of all time? Without a doubt. But he played in a lower level college program and his college “hardwood” is less then that of Howard or Tim Brown.

I’m ok with Peyton more so then Rice and the Niners are my NFL team
 
Holy crap did Pavelka make that list?!

Jim Rose?

B_MXgaGU0AAlhPU.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: PeliniTheCrutch
Just a hunch here, but they may have taken the NFL into consideration when making their list. How did Joe Montana miss the cut?
 
Rimington should be 1st team. The award for best center is named after him for chrissakes!! No better C in college. He dominated. Only 2 time Outland winner. One Lombardi.
Are you saying he's the Ray Guy (1st team punter) of centers?

Interestingly, both first-team kicking specialists (the other being Sebastian Janikowski) played for the Raider.
 
Yeah, how the hell can you leave Tommy Frazier off this list? 3 time MVP of the National championship game. Frazier was 32-3 with 4 conference championship and 2 national championship.

Roger Staubach Navy teams did nothing to brag about. navy went 3-6-1 his SR year. His best collegiate moment is getting his ass kicked by Texas in the Cotton bowl. A good portion of ESPNs write up on him is about playing for Dallas, which should be totally irrelevant to his college days. ESPN has one dam job and that’s to get sports right. Snub Johnny the Jet for the Rocket for APB and I’ll buy it. You can make the case for that. But no one, I mean no one, with any college football sense should snub Tommy from the best college QB of all time. Sports is 99.99999% subjective. Tommy is the 00.000001% that isn’t subject. It’s as much of a fact in sports as there is
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT